Let’s be real: Most nonprofit newsletters are snooze-fests. They’re too long, too generic, or worse—so boring they get deleted before they’re even opened. But a great newsletter? Now, that’s a game-changer. Done right, it strengthens relationships, builds awareness, and inspires action.
So how do you create a newsletter that people actually want to read? Here’s the roadmap.
Step 1: Get Clear on Your Newsletter’s Purpose
Your newsletter shouldn’t just be a box you check off. Every issue needs a clear purpose tied to your nonprofit’s mission. Is it to:
- Keep donors engaged with impact stories?
- Recruit and retain volunteers?
- Rally support for an upcoming campaign?
If your newsletter doesn’t move the needle on your goals, it’s time to rethink it.
Step 2: Name It With Intention
“Monthly Bulletin” or “Nonprofit Newsletter” won’t cut it. Give it a name that reflects your organization’s personality and purpose. Make it memorable. And when it lands in someone’s inbox, they should immediately know it’s from you—so brand it with your logo and colors front and center.
Step 3: Craft Content That Captivates
People open newsletters for value, not fluff. Here’s what works:
- Compelling Stories: Bring your mission to life with real people and real impact. Instead of saying, “Our program helped 500 people,” tell the story of one person whose life was changed.
- Behind-the-Scenes: Show donors and volunteers what happens behind closed doors—whether it’s a day in the life of a staff member, an upcoming initiative, or a sneak peek at an event.
- Calls to Action: Every newsletter should give readers something to do. Donate, sign up, share—make the ask clear and easy.
- Milestones & Wins: Celebrate progress. Share anniversary moments, program growth, and major achievements. People want to see success.
- Faces, Not Just Facts: Highlight board members, staff, or volunteers with short, engaging bios and a great photo. Human connection matters.
Step 4: Find the Right Frequency
Consistency is more important than frequency. A well-crafted newsletter every two months beats a rushed one every month. Pick a cadence you can maintain—whether it’s monthly, bi-monthly, or quarterly—and stick to it.
Step 5: Make It Easy to Read (and Act On!)
People don’t read—they skim. Make it effortless:
- Keep text short, punchy, and scannable.
- Use high-quality images to break up content.
- Choose clean, easy-to-read fonts that reflect your brand.
- Format it for mobile. If it’s clunky on a phone, no one’s reading it.
Step 6: Get It in Front of the Right People
Don’t let your newsletter disappear into the void. Get strategic with distribution:
- Email it with an engaging subject line—no one’s opening “Our October Update.”
- Share excerpts on social media to drive traffic to the full version.
- Print copies for in-person events or leave them in high-traffic community spaces.
Step 7: Be Patient—Engagement Takes Time
Your first few newsletters might not be blockbusters. That’s normal. Consistency builds trust, and over time, your audience will come to expect—and look forward to—your updates.
The bottom line? A newsletter isn’t just an email blast—it’s a relationship builder. Make it worth their time, and you’ll see the results.
Want More Nonprofit Growth Strategies?
Join the Success For Nonprofits Membership for exclusive resources, expert guidance, and a community of nonprofit professionals who get it. Get access to trainings, templates, and strategies to help you grow, engage, and fundraise effectively.
Click here to join now!
