How to Recruit and Retain Stellar Nonprofit Volunteers (Without Losing Your Mind)

Volunteers are the lifeblood of many nonprofits. They show up with passion, time, and energy—and all they ask for in return is a little respect, clear direction, and a sense that what they’re doing actually matters.

But let’s be real. Volunteer programs can feel like a revolving door. One day you’ve got a rockstar crew, the next you’re staring at a signup sheet with two names and a coffee stain.

Let’s break it down.

Step 1: Get Clear on What You Actually Need

Before you plaster “VOLUNTEERS NEEDED!” on every bulletin board in town, stop and ask yourself: What exactly do we need volunteers to do?

Be specific. Do you need someone to help with social media, sort donations, run a registration table, or wrangle toddlers at an event? General “help” is a fast track to no-shows and burnout—for everyone involved.

Make a list. Create actual job descriptions. Yes, even if the job is “decorate cupcakes.” People want to know what they’re signing up for—and it shows you respect their time.

Step 2: Recruit the Right People (Without Begging)

Desperation is not a good look. And guess what? You don’t need to beg. You need to inspire.

People want to be part of something meaningful. So ditch the guilt trip and tell a better story. Show them how volunteering with your organization makes a difference. Highlight real impact, not just tasks.

Tap into your network. Post engaging calls to action on social. Reach out to local schools, businesses, faith communities—anywhere people gather with good intentions and a bit of free time.

And yes, make it EASY to say yes. Make signing up to volunteer a simple process with fast response times. No “we’ll get back to you in 2-4 weeks” nonsense.

Step 3: Keep Them Engaged So They Don’t Disappear

You know what turns volunteers into ghosts? Confusion. Boredom. Chaos. Feeling like an extra, not part of the show.

Set people up for success. Train them. Communicate early and often. Introduce them to other team members. Check in after the first shift. Ask for feedback.

And for the love of all things nonprofit, don’t leave them standing around with no direction. A volunteer who shows up and feels useless may not show up again.

Step 4: Make Them Feel Valued (Hint: It Doesn’t Take Much)

Here’s a little secret: Appreciation doesn’t need to be a big production. A handwritten note. A quick thank-you email. A public shoutout. A bagel. These little gestures go a long, long way.

Better yet—make your volunteers feel seen. Learn their names. Ask about their experience. Invite them to share ideas. Remind them they’re part of the mission.

People don’t volunteer for the glory. But they do need to know they matter.

Bottom Line:

A stellar volunteer program doesn't require a six-figure budget or a full-time coordinator. It takes clarity, connection, and care. And if you can afford a volunteer coordinator—even part-time—go for it. A dedicated person managing volunteer relationships can be a game changer. But if that’s not in the budget, don’t panic. Just make sure someone on your team owns the role of supporting and stewarding volunteers. They deserve more than a once-a-year thank-you email and a T-shirt that almost fits.

Respect your volunteers, and they’ll move mountains for you.

Now, go forth and build that dream team!

If you need some social media templates that are designed to recruit, engage and thank volunteers, check out our Etsy Shop and this product: https://www.etsy.com/listing/1859489296/nonprofit-social-media-templates

‍