Finding the Right People to Fuel Your Nonprofit's Mission

Recruiting board members for your nonprofit can feel like trying to find the perfect pair of jeans—frustrating, often overwhelming, and not something you want to do too often. But the right board members? Oh, they’re magic. They bring expertise, passion, and a commitment to your mission that feels like sunshine on a cloudy day. So let’s talk about how to find those people—the unicorns who will propel your nonprofit forward.

1. Start with Your Why: Identify Your Nonprofit’s Needs and Gaps

Before you even think about names, take a step back. What does your organization need right now? Maybe you need financial expertise, someone with marketing savvy, or a connector with a deep Rolodex of potential donors. Whatever the case, your board should be more than a group of nice people who like your cause. Define your nonprofit’s needs and gaps. When you’re clear on your “why,” you can start finding the “who.”

2. Recruit Like You Mean It: How to Target Ideal Board Members

Stop treating board recruitment like it’s something that happens to you. Be proactive! This isn’t about hoping someone magically appears at your gala who’s dying to join your board. It’s about targeted, intentional outreach. Create a list of dream candidates—people you’ve met at events, seen in the news, or know from your network. Be specific about what you’re looking for and why you think they’d be a good fit. You’re not just filling a seat; you’re building a team.

3. Get Personal: The Power of One-on-One Board Recruitment

Nothing says “you’re not special” like a mass email. If you want someone to feel excited about your mission, you need to engage with them one-on-one. Invite them to coffee, lunch, or a site visit. Show them the impact of your work, and then tell them why you think they’d be a game-changer for your board. It’s not about what they can do for you—it’s about what you can accomplish together.

4. Set Expectations Early: Clear Communication with Potential Board Members

One of the biggest mistakes nonprofits make? Being vague about what they expect from their board members. When you’re recruiting, be crystal clear about the time commitment, financial contributions, meeting frequency, and any other responsibilities. No surprises. Think of it as dating—you want both parties to know what they’re getting into. No bait and switch.

5. Look Beyond the Usual Suspects: Diversify Your Nonprofit Board

The truth? Many nonprofits recruit board members from the same small pool of candidates, over and over again. Expand your horizons. Look for diverse voices that reflect the community you serve. Seek out individuals who bring different perspectives, life experiences, and skills to the table. Not only does this make your board stronger, but it also makes your organization more relevant and impactful.

6. Activate Your Current Board Members as Recruiters

Your best recruiters are often the people already sitting around your board table. Encourage them to think about their networks—friends, colleagues, even family members who might be a great fit. Make sure they understand your board recruitment priorities, so they’re equipped to help you find the right people. It’s not just the CEO’s job; it’s everyone’s job.

7. Make It Easy to Say Yes: Streamline Your Board Recruitment Process

Joining a board should feel like an honor, not a chore. Make the onboarding process welcoming and engaging. Provide orientation, mentoring, and clear paths for involvement. You want your new board members to feel like they’ve joined a team, not an old boys’ club with an initiation ritual. Think about it: the easier it is to say yes, the more likely you are to get a yes.

8. Follow Up and Stay Engaged: Keep Potential Board Members in the Loop

Even if someone says no today, it doesn’t mean no forever. Stay in touch with those you admire. Invite them to your events, keep them on your newsletter list, and continue to show them why your mission matters. Timing is everything, and when the time is right, they’ll be ready to jump in.

Bringing It All Together

Recruiting board members is about more than just filling seats. It’s about finding people who believe in your mission and are willing to roll up their sleeves to help you achieve it. So be bold. Be strategic. And most of all, be honest about what you need and why you’re asking. Because at the end of the day, the right board members won’t just serve your organization—they’ll champion it.

‍